This is the first in a series of posts, recording an e-conversation between John Baez (JB) and me (MW).

I have converted the first few posts into pdf files, formatted both for a small screen screen and a medium-sized one.

**JB: **I’ve lately been trying to learn about nonstandard models of Peano arithmetic. Do you know what a “recursively saturated” model is? They’re supposed to be important but I don’t get the idea yet.

**MW: **What books and/or papers are you reading? I used to know this stuff, indeed my thesis (1980) was on existentially complete models of arithmetic. When I looked at it a couple of years ago, I was amazed at how much I’d forgotten. Talk about depressing.

Anyway, I’ll toss out a few vague ideas, to see if they help. Maybe this will be the push I need to get back to Kaye’s book, or even Kossak & Schmerl. I picked them up a few months ago, hoping to revisit my youth, but I didn’t make it past the prefaces.

As Hodges puts it, model theory is “algebraic geometry minus fields”. If you have an algebraic number *r* in a extension field *K/F*, it’s natural to look at all the polynomials in *F*[*x*] which have *r* as a root. It turns out that this is a principal ideal, generated by the minimal polynomial.

Continue reading →