Mercury
Mercury refused to cooperate with Ptolemy’s basic paradigm. You might guess that the fault lies with Mercury’s larger eccentricity, but studies show that bad data bears most of the blame. Mercury hugs the Sun, only appearing near the horizon close to sunrise or sunset, hardly ideal observation conditions.
The Moon is the one solar body that does revolve around the Earth. It never displays retrogression. So you’d think Ptolemy wouldn’t “need no stinkin’ epicycles” for it. In fact, Ptolemy gave it a mechanism more complicated than that of any of the planets except Mercury! Here’s the model:
We now start the second part of this series: an in-depth look at the Ptolemaic system.
Origins of the Ptolemaic System
We’ve worked backwards from Kepler to Ptolemy. What inspired Ptolemy and his predecessors (Apollonius and Hipparchus) to come up with this scheme in the first place?
Speed Laws
In Ptolemy’s system, the point on the deferent moves uniformly as viewed from a point called the equant point, or sometimes just equant. The equant, the center of the deferent, and Earth all lie in a straight line, with the center midway between Earth and the equant.
Diagonal Argument 